UP CM Yogi Slams Rahul Gandhi Over Manusmriti Remark: 'Nation Doesn't Have High Expectations of You'
Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath sharply criticised Congress leader Rahul Gandhi over his recent observations on the 'Manusmriti', an ancient Indian legal text, saying the nation does not have high expectations of him. The remark adds to a series of political exchanges between the two leaders ahead of crucial elections.
Mr. Gandhi, during his recent visit to the United Kingdom, was asked about the Manusmriti's relevance to India's constitutional framework. In response, he reportedly said that India's Constitution is not based on Manusmriti and that the Constituent Assembly had deliberately rejected it in favour of modern democratic principles. His comments were later misquoted on social media, with some claiming he had called the Manusmriti the 'constitution of India'.
The controversy escalated as several right-wing groups condemned Mr. Gandhi's remarks. Addressing a gathering in Uttar Pradesh, Mr. Adityanath retorted: "The nation doesn't have high expectations of you." He further stated that those who lack knowledge of India's cultural heritage should avoid speaking on such topics.
The Manusmriti, traditionally attributed to the sage Manu, is a Sanskrit text that prescribes social and moral conduct. It has been both respected by some traditions and criticised by social reformers for its discriminatory provisions, particularly regarding caste and gender. The text has often been invoked in political debates, making it a point of contention.
Mr. Adityanath asserted that the Indian Constitution, drafted under the leadership of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, is supreme and does not draw its authority from any ancient text. He accused Mr. Gandhi of attempting to "mock" Hindu traditions in order to appeal to a particular vote bank. However, he did not provide specific evidence to support this charge.
Political observers note that the incident highlights the deep ideological divide between the two parties on questions of religion and history. While the BJP often projects itself as the custodian of Hindu culture, the Congress promotes a secular, liberal interpretation of the nation's heritage. This has led to frequent confrontations between their leaders.
Congress spokespersons have defended Mr. Gandhi, stating that his remarks were misinterpreted. They argued that he was only emphasising that India is a constitutional democracy, not a theocracy. "Rahul Gandhi respects all texts, but he rightly said that the Constitution is the ultimate guide," a senior Congress leader said on condition of anonymity.
This is not the first time Mr. Gandhi has faced criticism for his comments on Hindu scriptures. Earlier, he had said he was a "lord Shiva worshipper" while also criticising the RSS. The BJP has consistently accused him of being "anti-Hindu" in its rhetoric.
As the exchange continues, both parties are expected to capitalise on the controversy in their respective campaigns. The coming months may see further polarisation as elections approach.
